Judge first: is it grey or illegal? There is only one test
There is only one test: if this task were written out in full on a document to be submitted to a government agency, would you be willing to sign your name to it? If yes, it is probably an industry practice or a grey area. If no, you already know it is illegal. This test beats any statute because it requires no legal training.
By that test, several common instructions fall squarely on the illegal side: keeping two sets of books, booking personal spending as company expense, issuing invoices for transactions that never happened, passing funds of unknown origin through your personal or the company account, holding assets or shares in your name on your boss's behalf without real involvement, entering false information in tax or immigration filings, and taking part in any link of a gambling- or fraud-related operation. What these share is that, when investigated, the person who signed, handled, or holds the account is the first one questioned.
Other matters are genuinely grey and need case-by-case judgment: being required to work overtime that is paid as the rules require, being asked to post marketing from your personal account, being asked to sign a non-compete. These may be unfair without being unlawful, and the remedy is labor negotiation, which is outside this article's scope.
One more situation deserves separate mention: you are not sure. Your boss says this is normal, everyone does it, and you have doubts you cannot articulate. Do not guess. Write down the instruction itself (not your interpretation) in one sentence and ask a licensed lawyer who handles commercial or labor matters, once. That consultation costs less than any consequence that follows.
The point of judging is not to label your boss; it is to decide whether your next step is negotiation or exit.
Preserve evidence before you refuse: prove it was their demand, not your initiative
Evidence has one purpose: if this is ever investigated, you must be able to show that you were the party asked, that you refused, and that you did not profit. Those three points decide whether you are a witness or a suspect.
One, fix the instruction itself. Screenshot anything your boss sent on WeChat, email, or a group chat and back it up outside company systems. For anything said aloud, record the same day the time, place, who was present, and the exact words, and email it to yourself for a timestamp. If your boss habitually instructs only verbally and leaves no text, you can send a confirming message afterward: just to confirm, you asked me to record X as Y, have I understood correctly? Any reply is evidence, and no reply says something too.
Two, fix your refusal. How to word it is in the next section, but the principle is that the refusal must leave a written trace; a verbal refusal is no refusal.
Three, fix the fact that you did not profit. Accept no hardship pay, hush money, or bonus connected to the matter; accepting turns coercion into conspiracy. If you already have, stop immediately and consult a lawyer on how to handle it.
Four, fix your ordinary work. Your job description, the business you normally handle, your pay structure. These documents show that your actual job was lawful and the illegal demand was imposed on top of it.
Keep evidence within bounds: keep only material directly related to what you were asked to do. Do not go through other company accounts, do not copy customer data unrelated to you, do not send internal company documents to third parties. Overreaching evidence collection can itself be an offense and hands the other side material to counter-accuse you.
How to refuse: written, specific, non-accusatory, with a way out
The goal of refusing is I will not do this, and there is a record that I will not, rather than telling your boss he is breaking the law. The latter escalates immediately, and escalation does you no good before you have left.
Four principles for wording:
Written. Use email or the company's formal channel, not just a private chat. Email has a send time and a recipient and cannot be altered.
Specific. State exactly which request you are declining; do not write a general I will not do anything illegal. Write, for example, regarding your instruction to record the X expense under account Y, I am unable to carry this out, rather than I will not cook the books. Specificity ensures it cannot later be read as a refusal of something else.
Non-accusatory. Do not write this is illegal or this is laundering in your refusal. Your stated reason can be that this is outside my responsibilities, this does not match my understanding of the compliance requirements, or I need written confirmation from finance or legal before I can proceed. You are not convicting anyone; you are creating your own record.
With a way out. Add: if the company has a written policy basis or confirmation from the compliance function, please provide it. That sentence throws the ball back. A lawful instruction can be backed up; an unlawful one cannot, and he will not dare answer in writing.
Likely reactions after you refuse: assigning someone else (his affair; just record it); sidelining, reassignment, or a pay cut (a labor dispute with legal remedies); threatening your visa (handled in when an employer threatens to report you to immigration); or outright dismissal (your rights when dismissed are in what to do when you are suddenly fired). You now have a plan for each, so there is nothing to fear.
Exiting: in this order, and do not bolt
After refusing, you probably cannot stay at this company, but cannot stay and leave immediately are different things. An orderly exit runs as follows.
First, sort out your status. When your 9G, employment permit, and residency card each expire, and whether you have a new employer or another status route, determine how much time you have. Do not resign before the status route is clear, because a 9G is tied to the employer and the timing of resignation must dovetail with the status conversion. Stay options after losing a job are in lawful stay options after losing a job.
Second, resign formally, through proper procedure. Give written notice for the period the contract and the law require; do not walk out. Walking out turns you from the employee who refused an illegal instruction into the employee who abandoned the job, handing the other side material to counter-accuse you. If your resignation is refused or you are held back, see when the company refuses your resignation.
Third, collect everything you are owed on departure. Separation certificate, unpaid wages, statutory amounts, personal belongings. Do not give these up to leave faster, and do not sign anything confirming the company did nothing wrong or that you resigned voluntarily with no dispute.
Fourth, after leaving, all contact with the company stays in writing. Accept no further instructions related to your old role, log into no company system, do no one any favors. If they use the separation certificate or unpaid wages as leverage to keep you cooperating, that is fresh coercion; record it and consult a lawyer.
Fifth, consider whether to inform the authorities. That is the next section.
The most important point throughout: do not tell colleagues that you are preserving evidence and preparing to leave. You do not know who will tell the boss, and once he knows, retaliation may arrive before you are out.
Whether to inform the authorities: a decision to make with a lawyer, never alone
After refusing and leaving, you face a genuine decision: whether to proactively tell the authorities what you know. Do not make it alone; make it with a licensed lawyer, because it involves both your legal exposure and your safety.
Reasons to inform: if the company is investigated later, your name will appear in the books, signatures, or accounts, and explaining then that you were coerced carries far less weight than having come forward beforehand. Coming forward is the most effective way to move yourself from suspect to witness, and in some situations the law gives weight to voluntary cooperation.
Risks of informing: your statement may trigger an investigation of the company, and the other side may learn who spoke; if organized illegal activity is involved, your personal safety needs assessing; and your residency status may be affected during the investigation. These risks can be managed, but a lawyer must assess and arrange them; do not go in on your own.
Whom to inform depends on the nature of the matter: tax issues go to the tax authority; questions about the source of funds go to the anti-money-laundering bodies; gambling- or fraud-related matters go to the police and relevant enforcement units; labor rights matters go to the labor department. A lawyer will help you determine which, how, and how much.
If the matter already involves a criminal investigation, or you have received any summons, stop all self-handling immediately and hand everything to a lawyer; the consequences and response are in how a criminal complaint affects a foreigner's visa.
If you believe your personal safety is threatened, this is no longer a labor or compliance matter; secure your safety first and consider the rest afterward. Chinese citizens can contact the consular protection section of the Chinese embassy or consulate in the Philippines.
What Yixing can help with, and one sentence for anyone still hesitating
The boundary first: whether something is illegal, whether to inform the authorities, and how to respond to a possible investigation are for a licensed lawyer. Yixing is a private consultancy, not a law firm. But in these situations the first thing that traps a foreign employee is usually my status is tied to this company, I simply cannot leave, and that problem is exactly what Yixing works on every day.
What Yixing can do: verify the actual status and remaining time on your 9G, employment permit, and residency card; map which status conversion routes you have, what documents each needs, and how the timing runs, so your resignation date can dovetail with the conversion; assist with the visa handover to a new employer where you have one; assist with a transitional lawful stay where you do not yet have one; and find and engage a lawyer who handles commercial, labor, and immigration matters. For that assistance, see Yixing settling-in advisory.
Yixing International Travel Agency is a Chinese-language business consultancy registered in Makati, Philippines, holding SEC Registration CS202009551, Bureau of Immigration Accreditation No. CA-202624381-1 (valid to 2027-06-30), DOLE accreditation and PRA accreditation. We are not affiliated with any government agency and promise no outcome.
One sentence for anyone still hesitating: the just this once you are weighing is, in law, no different from ten times, and after the first time your boss holds one more thing over you. How to choose a lawyer is in how to find a reliable lawyer in the Philippines. Consult a licensed lawyer for your specific case; this article is not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
My boss told me to cook the books. I'm only following instructions. Am I liable?
How do I know whether what my boss asked is really illegal?
When I refuse, should I tell my boss it's illegal?
After I refused, my boss threatened my visa. What now?
Should I just stop showing up and leave right away?
Should I go to the government and report what I know?
What can Yixing help with?
Let’s talk through your situation — free
Every company is different. Leave your details and a Chinese-speaking advisor will get back within 1 business day with practical, industry-specific guidance and a transparent quote.
Get help with Chinese Community → Free consultation
