First response: no promissory note, no agreed figure, written details
In the moment, avoid three things: signing a promissory note or repayment agreement, saying you will pay it back gradually, and agreeing that the sum can come out of your wages or final pay. A promissory note is not the same as a payroll deduction. It is a free-standing acknowledgement of debt, and the company can enforce it even after you have left and even if its original accusation would not have held. Many people treat signing as a formality and then discover the figure is wrong when it is too late to disown their signature.
What you should do is turn the verbal demand into a written one. Reply that you would like a written notice setting out the specific loss, the basis for holding you responsible and the computation, and that you will respond in writing. This does two things. It forces a vague complaint to be tied to particular facts, and many claims shrink at that stage. It also fixes the company's first version of events, so that the demand cannot be quietly enlarged later.
If you are told to sign immediately, or that you cannot go home until you do, remember that the company has no authority to restrain you or to take your phone or documents. Say that you need time to check the details and take a copy of whatever was shown to you. Afterwards write down the time, the place, who was present and the words used, and send the note to your private email. If the loss is described as something you took, and not something that went missing, the matter has become an accusation of theft, and the order of steps is in accused of theft by your employer.
Is it yours to pay? Business risk, ordinary negligence and gross fault
Separate three situations: ordinary business risk, simple negligence, and deliberate or gross fault. A customer who fails to pay, normal loss in transit, equipment that wears out, and losses from price movements are risks of doing business. In principle the employer bears them, and they do not become yours because your name is on the paperwork. Sales staff are often told to stand behind bad debts. Where the contract contains no clear undertaking and the company approved the credit, that demand is difficult to sustain.
Simple negligence, such as knocking over a monitor while moving it or miscounting a carton, is the sort of error that happens at work. The company may impose discipline under its handbook, but full reimbursement does not automatically follow. Relevant questions include whether training and safeguards were provided and how similar incidents were handled before. Deliberate damage, loss caused by a serious breach of a clear operating rule, or cash and property in your sole custody that you cannot account for are different. In those cases the employer's claim is considerably stronger.
Ask factual questions as well. Were you the only person with custody, or did others have access? Were you present when the loss occurred? Did the company hold insurance, and has the insurer paid? Was the figure based on purchase price or on depreciated value? Has the loss been shared among everyone involved? You do not need to answer these on the spot; they are the points you ask the company to address in your written reply. Whether common items such as deposits, cash shortages and uniform or tool charges may be deducted is analysed one by one in unlawful salary deductions.
Can they deduct it from your pay? Only with proof, a hearing and a fair amount
The company cannot decide alone and then deduct from wages; labour rules attach conditions to deductions for loss or damage. In general the employer must be able to show that the employee is clearly responsible, must give the employee a reasonable opportunity to explain why no deduction should be made, must keep the amount fair and no greater than the actual loss, and must keep each deduction within a set proportion of wages. Check the current labour department rule for that proportion. If any one of these elements is missing, the deduction may be held unlawful.
Finding out on payday that a large amount is missing is therefore already a procedural problem. Ask for the payslip, ask in writing for the basis of the deduction, and state that you do not agree. Keep that email, because accepting pay in silence is sometimes described later as consent. If the company produces a general clause you signed at hiring stating that employees bear all losses, do not assume the matter is closed. A blanket waiver made in advance is not automatically valid, and its effect depends on its wording and the circumstances in which it is invoked.
Withholding the whole of your final pay is another familiar move, with the explanation that it will be released once compensation is settled. An unproven claim does not justify holding earned wages indefinitely. How to press for payment, and when to file, is covered in final pay withheld for months. A further variant is a release document stating that you give up your final pay in exchange for the loss being written off. Before signing anything of that kind, read whether to sign a quitclaim carefully.
You may not leave until you pay: why that does not hold
A rule that you cannot resign until you have paid has no legal footing, because resignation is the employee's own right and does not depend on consent. Submit a written resignation with the statutory notice, and the employment ends when the notice period runs out, whether or not anyone signs or approves it. An unresolved claim for compensation is a separate matter to be pursued by lawful means, and it is not a ground for keeping a person at work. How to serve the letter, and the usual stalling tactics, are in when the employer refuses your resignation.
Each common way of blocking a departure has an answer. Holding your passport or ACR card is not allowed, so demand their return in writing. Refusing to process clearance misuses a procedure meant for returning company property, not for extracting a promissory note; see resignation and clearance. Refusing a certificate of employment ignores the fact that the certificate is a statutory entitlement regardless of any dispute. Labelling you as absent without leave fails if you served written notice and completed a turnover. Posting someone at your dormitory or stopping you from collecting personal belongings is a matter of personal liberty and should be reported to the police.
If you want to leave at once without serving the notice period, weigh the cost first using resigning with immediate effect. Bear in mind that an unlawful refusal to release you does not make the underlying claim disappear. The company may still bring a civil claim after you go, or file a criminal complaint if it has evidence. Having your written reply, turnover list and supporting documents in order before your last day matters more than the act of walking out.
Negotiate or contest: when to settle and how to word it
Where you really are at fault, agreeing a reasonable figure in a properly drafted document is often better than resisting. Assess three things for yourself: whether the loss is real, how serious your fault was, and whether the figure is inflated. If all three go against you, you may propose terms, subject to some limits. The amount should not exceed the actual loss after insurance recoveries and depreciation. The document should say it is a full and final settlement and that the company will make no further claim on the same matter. Any instalments should be affordable. Every payment needs a receipt. Do not make an informal transfer on the strength of a conversation.
Avoid wording such as I admit stealing or I misappropriated, unless that is true and a lawyer is already involved, because a civil settlement can be produced as evidence in a criminal case. Do not combine the settlement with a resignation in one document; write and sign them separately. Give yourself time to have someone qualified read the draft, even if that is only one day.
Where you believe you should not pay, contest it through the proper steps. File a written reply with evidence. If money has already been deducted, demand its return in writing. If talks fail, request conciliation at the labour department and go to arbitration only if that does not resolve it. Which office handles which kind of claim is explained in how to file a labour complaint, and the route for unpaid wages generally is in recovering unpaid wages. If you fear being targeted at work after complaining, read retaliation after a labour complaint and start keeping records. Whether to settle or fight in your case is a question for a licensed lawyer.
Foreign employees: held passports, visa threats and where Yixing fits
When a foreign employee is asked to pay, the employer appears to hold two extra cards, your passport and your work visa, but neither is as strong as it looks. A passport belongs to the issuing state, and an employer may not keep it for any reason. If the company has it, demand its return in writing with a deadline, and if it is still not returned, seek help from the police and your consulate. As for the threat to cancel your 9G or report you for illegal work, an employer may indeed apply to cancel after the employment ends, but cancellation does not make you unlawful overnight. There is room to downgrade or change status, as explained in threats to report you to immigration.
Keep your own timetable: the expiry dates of the visa and the ACR card, the date your resignation takes effect, and the downgrade steps that follow a cancellation request. The real risk is failing to deal with status once the employment is over. The steps before departure are set out in downgrading a 9G work visa. Remember also that if the claim is escalated into a criminal complaint, your ability to leave the country may be affected, so do not depart abruptly in the middle of a heated dispute.
Yixing International is a private consultancy registered with the Philippine Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC Registration No. CS202009551). It holds Bureau of Immigration accreditation (BI Accreditation No. CA-202624381-1, valid until 2027-06-30) and is accredited with DOLE and the PRA. It is not part of any government office. In disputes like this we assist with status and paperwork: verifying where your visa and permit stand, processing a downgrade or a transfer to a new employer through the regular procedure, and organising the documents immigration requires, as described under visa and HR services. Liability and the amount in dispute are legal questions. Consult a licensed lawyer about your individual case. This article is not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse to sign a promissory note for company losses?
Can the company make a salesperson pay for a customer's bad debt?
Is it legal to deduct compensation from my salary without my consent?
The company will not accept my resignation until I pay. What now?
Can my employer keep my passport until I pay?
I damaged equipment. Must I pay the full purchase price?
Can the company pursue me after I have left?
Let’s talk through your situation — free
Every company is different. Leave your details and a Chinese-speaking advisor will get back within 1 business day with practical, industry-specific guidance and a transparent quote.
Get help with Visa & HR → Free consultation