Day one: secure the bill, get the charge schedule, send a written demand
When the refusal arrives, first confirm that title is still in your hands: the originals have not been sent to the buyer, no telex release has been issued, and any documents under a letter of credit or collection are still with the bank. As long as the bill is with you or the bank, the buyer cannot take delivery and you keep the right to dispose of the goods. If a telex release has been given or the originals have been dispatched, write at once to the carrier and the forwarder asking them to hold delivery because payment is in dispute; whether that works depends on whether the release has already been carried out. Second, ask the forwarder or the carrier's destination agent to state in writing when free storage and free container time expire, what the daily charges are afterwards, how they step up, and from what date customs treats undeclared cargo as abandoned. Those dates tell you how many days you have to negotiate.
Third, send the buyer a formal written demand. Quote the contract and order number, state that the cargo has arrived, require payment and collection by a named date, and say that after that date you will dispose of the goods and claim the price difference, port charges and other losses. Send it by email and by courier and keep proof of delivery. Many buyers are testing how far you will bend, and a clear demand with a firm date resolves a fair share of refusals on its own. For how such letters work in the Philippines see what a demand letter does. If the bill itself is lost or controlled by someone else, see lost or withheld bill of lading.
Find out why the buyer is refusing: four causes, four ways to negotiate
The real reason decides how you should negotiate, so look at what the buyer does, not only at what it says. The first cause is a market move: local prices fell while the goods were at sea and the buyer wants a lower price or no deal at all. That buyer still wants the goods, only not at the old price, and a sensible discount with fast completion usually costs less than shipping back. The second cause is cash: the buyer wants the goods and cannot fund the balance. You can agree staged payment with staged release, but release documents only against cleared funds for each lot and do not release first out of sympathy. The third cause is a missing import qualification or product permit. Regulated goods without the right licence cannot clear customs at all. Another buyer that holds the licence may be able to take them; otherwise the realistic route is a return shipment, covered in returning rejected cargo.
Only the fourth cause is a real dispute about quality or quantity. Ask the buyer for a specific written objection with evidence. If the goods have not cleared customs, the buyer has normally had no chance to open and inspect them, and a quality objection at that stage is often a bargaining move. Where a deviation is real, follow the inspection and claims clause in the contract and propose a jointly appointed surveyor. In every case set a deadline for the talks and keep them in writing. The sooner you know the true cause, the sooner you can decide before charges consume the value of the goods. For payment structures that prevent this position see getting paid by Philippine buyers.
Route one: resell locally, usually the smallest loss, but the bill must be amended
If the goods have a market in the Philippines, finding another local buyer is the most common route and usually the least costly; what matters is speed and paperwork. Canvass quickly through trade contacts, exhibition leads, industry groups and local traders, and price in the port charges already incurred instead of expecting the new buyer to absorb them all. Once you have a taker, you must apply to the carrier to change the consignee and notify party on the bill. Only the shipper can give that instruction, and the carrier will charge an amendment fee and require the full set of originals to be surrendered. If the goods have already been entered with customs in the first buyer's name, changing the consignee becomes more involved, and a licensed customs broker should confirm the current practice before you commit to the sale.
The new buyer must hold its own importer accreditation and whatever permits the product requires; otherwise you have only moved the problem from one buyer to another. Make the payment terms more conservative than last time: release against cleared funds, or at least after most of the price has been received. The gap between the resale price and the original contract price, together with the extra port charges and the amendment fee, forms the core of your later claim against the first buyer. Keep the whole resale file, including quotations sought, the new contract and every receipt, so that you can show you acted reasonably to reduce the loss and did not simply dump the goods. For the broker's role at this stage see forwarder versus customs broker.
Routes two and three: ship the goods back, or abandon them after doing the sums
With no local taker, the choice is between return and abandonment, and it is arithmetic. A return shipment costs the return freight, the storage and container charges already accrued at destination, the handling for the re-export, and the import formalities at home. Add these and compare them with what the goods will be worth once they are back. High-value, generic, non-perishable goods are worth returning. Low-value, bulky, customised or short-dated goods often mean paying more to carry the loss home. Philippine customs has its own procedure for returning cargo, which needs a stated reason and a customs broker; whether it is approved and how long it takes follow the customs rules in force at the time. The steps are set out in returning rejected cargo and who pays.
Abandonment is not the same as walking away. Once the goods are treated as abandoned, customs disposes of them, but the carrier's container charges and the terminal charges can be claimed from the shipper and the consignee named on the bill, so the carrier may well turn to you as shipper. If you decide to abandon, send the carrier and the forwarder a written declaration, agree how the charges will be closed out, and obtain written confirmation of that settlement. What you must not do is stop answering emails and calls and let the cargo sit indefinitely. That leaves you without the goods and with an open-ended bill. For ways to contain the charges while you decide see stopping demurrage and storage from piling up.
Claiming against the buyer: what you can claim, where, and how realistic it is
Recovery comes after the goods have been dealt with. A seller can usually claim three things: the difference between the contract price and the resale price, the additional port and transport costs caused by the refusal, and any liquidated damages or interest the contract provides for. A deposit already received is handled as the contract says. Whether you can actually recover depends first on the contract: does it define the buyer's liability for refusal, which law governs, and where are disputes resolved. If it provides for arbitration or litigation in China, an award or judgment obtained there must still be recognised and enforced in the Philippines. If it is silent or names the Philippines, you proceed there. The routes are compared in mediation, arbitration or court.
Realistically, cross-border recovery is not cheap. For modest sums a negotiated settlement is often worth more than a judgment. Where the amount is small and the buyer has a real presence in the Philippines, check whether the claim falls within the small claims procedure described in small claims court in the Philippines. Success also depends on whether the buyer is a real company with assets, which is why counterparties should be checked before the next order. If you hold export credit insurance, refusal to take delivery is a commonly covered risk. Notify the insurer within the period set by the policy and dispose of the goods as it directs, because a distress sale without its consent can prejudice the claim. All of this rests on a complete written record: the contract, your demand, the buyer's refusal, the disposal process and the receipts.
How to stop a refusal from holding you hostage next time, and what Yixing can do
A seller is exposed to refusal because the goods are at the buyer's door while the money is not yet in the seller's account. Every remedy sits before shipment: a deposit large enough to cover freight both ways and port charges, a balance payable against a copy of the bill and not on arrival, a letter of credit or at least a bank collection for new customers, and a contract that spells out liability for refusal, who bears the costs and how disputes are resolved. Before shipping, confirm that the buyer's importer accreditation and any product permits are in place and ask for the documents, not an assurance. Run a basic check on the Philippine buyer: is the registration current, does the business address exist, has it left unpaid suppliers behind. For large orders consider export credit insurance, and keep one person responsible for tracking document status from loading to delivery.
Yixing Travel Consultancy (SEC Registration No. CS202009551, Bureau of Immigration Accredited Agency No. CA-202624381-1) offers compliance retainer services to foreign-owned companies in the Philippines and to exporters selling into the country: verification of a Philippine counterparty's registration and operating status, local preparation of contracts and demand documents, introductions to licensed customs brokers and licensed counsel, and an assessment of whether setting up your own sales entity to act as importer makes sense. We are not a customs broker or a law firm and we do not promise any recovery or resale result. If your cargo is sitting at port now, bring the contract, the status of the bill, the buyer's refusal emails and the forwarder's charge schedule, and we will work through the numbers on all three routes with you. For your specific case consult a licensed lawyer; this article is not legal advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
The buyer no longer wants the cargo at a Philippine port. Are the goods still mine?
Who pays storage and container charges after the buyer refuses?
Can I resell the goods to another buyer in the Philippines?
Is shipping the goods back worth it?
Can I just leave the cargo at the port?
The buyer claims a quality problem, but the goods have not cleared customs. How should I respond?
Can I claim damages from a Philippine buyer who refused delivery?
Let’s talk through your situation — free
Every company is different. Leave your details and a Chinese-speaking advisor will get back within 1 business day with practical, industry-specific guidance and a transparent quote.
Get help with Compliance & Retainer → Free consultation